Using this resource
The ´Ten Steps towards Systems Thinking´ are arranged along the dimensions Recognizing, Evaluating, and Acting (UNESCO, 2017, p. 91). The steps begin with simple description of reality (recognizing), leading to progressive, comprehensive and deeper analytic understanding (evaluating), and therefore preparation to act more strategically (acting).
Educators, teachers, community or youth facilitators contribute in different ways to develop systems thinking among learners, though the practice is not widespread. One reason is that most school curricula as well as teacher education programmes do not offer a structured approach to developing systems thinking competence. We recommend this manual as a practical learning teaching-learning resource to bridge this gap.
The next sections present a step-by-step guide to exploring and learning about systems
Systems thinking is the ability to describe and/ or visualise a part of a complex reality, express that part of reality as a model, understand the model as a system, use the model to explain the behaviour of the system, anticipate the behaviour of the system, and evaluate its impacts on sustainable development, identify potential points of, and types of interventions, generate options to act, assess their impacts in the frame of sustainable development, and decide whether further actions are necessary or not.
Steps | Dimensions | |
---|---|---|
From recognizing to modelling | Step 1 : Recognize a complex part of reality | Recognizing |
Step 2 : Express that part of reality as a model | ||
Step 3 : Understand the model as a system | ||
Working with a model of a system to understand the future | Step 4: Use the model to explain the behaviour of the system | |
Step 5 : Anticipate the behaviour of the system | Assessing | |
Step 6 : Evaluate the current and potential results of the system behaviour in the frame of sustainable development | ||
Working with a model to influence the future | Step 7 : Identify potential points of intervention in the system | |
Step 8 : Identify potential types of intervention in the system | ||
Step 9 : Generate outlooks and options to act for sustainable development | Acting | |
Step 10 : Assess impacts of actions in the frame of sustainable development, and decide whether further actions are necessary or not. | Assessing |
The ten steps are based on the definition already introduced in the section “What is ‘Systems Thinking’ Competence?”. Each of these steps is described as a chapter in the following sections.
The staircase
We invite users to imagine The Ten Steps like an ancient staircase, with steps of different heights leading to a different (higher) level. While climbing, while one foot is reaching the next step, the other foot rests behind. Each step enhances systems understanding, building upon the previous step and leading on to the next.
Note that you (and your learners or participants) don’t have to scale all the ten steps at one go. It is possible to develop one’s systems thinking competence by taking a few steps at a time.
You may climb one step easily, but find another a little challenging. You might start to climb but not manage to complete a step, and have to make another attempt.
In each Step, certain activities and tasks are suggested that use different Learning Methods. You can find all the learning methods in alphabetical order in the Appendix. Some steps also refer to Worksheets or Information Sheets. You can also find these in the Appendix. We suggest these learning methods and materials as handrails to help the climbers on their journey. In a group of climbers, one may lend a helping hand to another. So, it is with the learning process, with participants contributing different ideas and abilities to the group learning process.
At the end of each step, a few ‘further leading questions’ are suggested, which help in guiding the participants’ thinking to the next step.
The Sustainable Development competences likely to be enhanced in each step are indicated using a radar chart such as the one presented below.
We have included such a graphic for each of the Ten Steps. They show the type of SD competences that might be developed in the individual steps. Do note that these are only indicative of a low, medium, or strong possibility of competence enhancement, and not definitive representations.
We just want to provide a hint to the facilitator that the indicated competences may be enhanced. Note that the opportunity and realization of competence strengthening depends on each learning situation, the facilitator, and the learners. Therefore, we present these graphics in only the theory segment of the Ten Steps and not in the examples.
We encourage you as a facilitator and educator to think about the SD competence framework when preparing learning approaches and methods. The radar graphic is a tool to help you in your reflection on how the activities and learning methods you select might help in developing different SD competences. At the end of each step, you may use the graphic as a tool to recapitulate with learners what was done in the step and whether they felt such competences were gained.
This manual presents two examples of how to apply the Ten Steps of Systems Thinking. Two items that may be familiar to young people around the world – jeans and chips – are the main characters in these examples.
Millions of people are dressed in jeans every day. Learners across campuses prefer wearing jeans. We may have our favourite brands. Some of us may simply wear the ones that are affordable. Others prefer those that are most stylish, or comfortable to wear for daily work. As many of us know, jeans are mostly made of cotton (though fast fashion is driving up the use of polyester). However, we might not really know where the jeans were made and how, and who made them. Nor would we know the conditions in which the jeans were made, and who benefitted or profited from the making and the selling of the jeans, and what negative impact it had on the environment.
Following these few thoughts, you may directly enter the global cotton system. A global pattern of production steps has evolved from the different climatic and farming conditions, availability of water for irrigation, work conditions and earnings of farmers and factory workers, industrial processes, status of environmental laws and many other factors. This global system is in a continuous state of change.
As mentioned earlier, the jeans we wear is only one of the outcomes of this system. What else is happening in this system and how does it affect our world? This example of an everyday item of our lives has been chosen to invite learners to systems thinking.
All over the world, potato chips of various flavours – traditional, classic, tangy, and even some flavours that many might find strange – have the leading position among all snacks. Nutrition habits all over the world show a remarkable change from the previous years, and chips accompany the increasing screen time due to Television, multi-media, video, internet, online learning, and work settings. Snacking and snacks are on the rise, especially among youth. The unfortunate element of the story is that a chips-heavy diet is unhealthy, so far.
The potato chip navigates the journey from a potato field to the bag of chips in our hands through a global production system. The journey follows the chips through the human body which is a system on its own. These two, separate but linked, sub-systems form a complex system.
The ‘Chips’ example with its linked sub-systems presents a progression within systems learning.
The Example Approach
This manual is designed for flexible use, in accordance with the needs of the users. We aim to motivate you as an Educator and Facilitator to create your own material to use with your learners, in Ten (or more, or less) Steps towards systemic thinking.
We hope that the activities and methods presented will guide you in strengthening your learners’ systems thinking abilities not only for the topics we have included, but for many others of your preference.
Through the ten steps we present suggestions that you can adapt to your context and needs. We also illustrate the use of certain methods. Both examples try to use different methods and activities for learners to acquire different competencies suggested in each step.
How may one identify a suitable topic for the development of systems thinking competence? Here are some pointers to keep in mind:
When starting, it may be appropriate to choose familiar topics and local scales – these may not be less complex, but easier to understand.
Here are examples of topics that you may find suitable to explore:
- items like jeans, chips or other food items, car, wooden house
- activities and processes like traffic and waste management
- natural phenomenon in which humans have intervened, like climate (change), soil formation and dynamics, water cycle.
You can choose a starting point for your Ten Step exploration: start with an everyday item or situation in your city or village, or analyse a part of nature that you and your learners are concerned about or interested in.
Topics most suited for exploring sustainability issues with a systems approach would touch social, political, economic and environmental dimensions, and could have multiple scales – individual, family, community, region, state/ nation, and the whole world.
Figure 1 is intended to help you choose or appropriately frame a topic for Systems learning. The chart presents different dimensions (social affairs, economy etc) and scales (represented in different colours) of development, that may be considered when choosing and analysing topics. The red line in the graphic indicates that some topics extend beyond state and country limits.
To check whether a topic would be suitable for Systems learning or not, you could draw a chart (or use the table template below) and add key words in each segment, relating to the theme (social, economy, politics, environment) and the scale (individual, community, etc). The more populated the template is, the better. Realizing the complexity of issues is a valuable insight.
You may also refer to the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), and their targets to find inspiration for systems thinking topics. It is very valuable to have young minds grapple with the challenges that the SDGs present.
Template to add keywords to detail out a topic | ||||
Topic: | ||||
Scale/ Dimension | Social Affairs | Economy | Politics | Environment |
Individual | ||||
Family, small group | ||||
Community | ||||
Region | ||||
Nation, state | ||||
Transnational (across national boundaries) unit | ||||
World |